The resume was wrong for the role.
No industry experience. No manufacturing background. A career spent entirely in IT. The hiring manager across the table made that clear before the conversation even started. On paper this was not the candidate.
But three hours over coffee had told a different story.
The way he leaned forward when a problem came up. The napkin sketches that appeared before anyone asked for them. The passion in his voice when he talked about what better performance could actually mean for the people depending on the system. He was not describing a job. He was describing something he genuinely cared about.
That is not on a resume.
The hiring manager had concerns and they were legitimate. Senior role. High stakes. The safe choice was someone whose background matched the job description line by line. That is how most hiring decisions get made, by matching what someone has done to what the role requires, and calling the closest match qualified.
But a resume is a record of the past. It tells you where someone has been. It says almost nothing about what they will do when the problem is hard, the pressure is real, and nobody is watching.
Character does not show up in a work history. Passion does not appear under skills. The willingness to care more than the job requires is never listed under qualifications.
Those things show up in a conversation. In the way someone talks about work they love. In the energy that surfaces when the problem gets interesting. In the small unrequested moments, a sketch on a napkin, a question that goes deeper than necessary, a answer that reveals someone who is not just capable but genuinely invested.
The best managers I learned from taught me something that took a long time to fully understand. You do not hire credentials. You hire character. You hire passion.
You can't teach someone to give a damn.
If hiring decisions like this are sitting on your desk right now, I am happy to think through it with you. No agenda. Just a conversation. You can find me at dieleconsulting.com.
Imported from Post Archives — Week of JUN 29 Posts.docx